
It may seem perverse with a Russian orchestra to have the least Russian-sounding orchestration of
Pictures,
albeit the most inspired one. Yet Carlo Ponti, so far as he can, brings
out the Russian-ness of Mussorgsky’s inspiration with each of the
pictures sharply characterised and with much delicate playing in such
items as “The Fair at Limoges” set against the weight of the
tuttis,
notably in the final “Great Gate at Kiev”. That goes with recording of
extreme dynamic range, arguably too extreme for domestic comfort. The
wind solos are specially impressive, as is the horn descant in the
“Great Gate of Kiev”. In short, an excellent version of a much-recorded
showpiece.
Night on the Bare Mountain comes in the highly unauthentic but undeniably effective Rimsky version, brilliantly played here with powerful bite. The
Khovanshchina excerpts
make an effective, atmospheric filler, but the disc offers rather short
measure at just on an hour. The Super Audio recording adds to the
impact of the performances, well engineered by Pentatone technicians
trained by Philips.
(Edward Greenfield / Gramophone, 6/2009)
Comentarios
Publicar un comentario