Philharmonie Zuidnederland / Dmitri Liss / Christianne Stotijn HENDRIK ANDRIESSEN Miroir de peine HECTOR BERLIOZ Symphonie fantastique

MIROIR DE PEINE - SYMPHONIE FANTASTIQUE

Stockholm Syndrome Ensemble VOICES OF ANGELS

VOICES OF ANGELS

Jakub Hrůša / Jiří Bělohlávek / Czech Philharmonic DVORÁK Requiem

                                                                      REQUIEM

Boston Symphony Orchestra / Thomas Adès ADÈS CONDUCTS ADÈS

                                                     ADÈS CONDUCTS ADÈS

Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra / Ed Spanjaard / Christianne Stotijn MICHEL VAN DER AA Spaces of Blank - Mask - Imprint

The three works on this first CD by Disquiet Media, composer, film-maker and director Michel van der Aa’s own multimedia label, together constitute a stylistic cross-section of a genre that, with its refined musical expression of conceptual first principles, has quickly gained ground both nationally and internationally. They demonstrate the scope of a vision of ‘music about music’, in which as an object of study the human being, musician or not, is just as important as musical ideas. When Van der Aa says he is not a composer of notes, he means he is not only concerned with the creative dialogue with forms and musical languages but also with the theatrical aspects of music-making, perceived with the detachment of the principled outsider who constantly asks himself what and how he sees and hears.

His attention is directed primarily to the physical and social facets of music-making: producing sound, the musician as a recreative individual, relationships between musicians, ensemble structure and the interpretative ritual per se, which in his case consistently assumes theatrical forms because human beings form the active centre point. No less essential are the aural and visual perceptions of the listener, with whom the composer plays a peculiarly serious cat-and-mouse game. Van der Aa imperceptibly transforms acoustic sounds into electronic ones, or manipulates them beyond recognition by electronic means, thus creating a sound universe that arouses a permanent state of wonder: what am I hearing, what is meant by this?

As in One, the opera After Life and The Book of Disquiet centre on characters that, thrown upon themselves, are faced with the question who they are and how they relate to their world. It is probably clear by now that only a blurred distinction exists between Van der Aa’s concert and theatre music. The solitary soprano in Here [in circles] and Here [to be found] struggles on the concert podium with the same issues as the protagonist in One: whither, wherefore? Despite their thematic material, the same holds true for the three works on this CD. Imprint, for Baroque orchestra, is seemingly the most musicianly, the ensemble piece Mask as an essay about the relationship between form and sound the most conceptual, and the song cycle Space of Blank the most dramatic, but the common denominators stand out. They deal with the lone wolf and his relationship – or absence of it – to his biotope. (Bas van Putten)

Christianne Stotijn / Julius Drake TCHAIKOVSKY Romances

 This is a stunningly beautiful disc, and can be recommended without reservation to anyone who loves the vocal repertoire. I am not enough of a linguist to know if the Dutch mezzo’s Russian is perfectly pronounced, though I can say her diction is clear with crisp consonants. And the disc has direct competition from Philips 442013—a disc of Tchaikovsky songs sung by the great Russian Olga Borodina. Thirteen of the 20 songs on Stotijn’s disc are duplicated on Borodina’s, and as much as I like this, I would find it hard to recommend that kind of duplication to the casual song collector. But for the serious collector, or to anyone who doesn’t have the Borodina, I will state a slight preference for this disc.
One difference is at the piano. Larissa Gergieva plays quite well for Borodina, but Julius Drake is one of the most imaginative and accomplished song accompanists working today, and he brings something special to the piano parts here. But that is not to minimize the accomplishments of Christianne Stotijn. I find a greater range of color and imagination in her timbre and her inflections and phrasing. The hushed beauty of the end of “My Genius, My Angel, My Friend” is quite remarkable, and at the other extreme so is the drama and passion of “Had I Only Known.” She can float gorgeous soft tones, or she can open up full throttle without any edge to the voice. These are highly communicative and deeply moving performances of some very beautiful songs.
Fine notes, complete texts (transliterated and English—no Cyrillic), and extremely natural well-balanced sound quality round out this very special recording. (FANFARE: Henry Fogel)